tlp, did a lifelong disorder?
PERSON-PSI.Dra. Averbach and Luis TESZKIEWICZ Marina.
Thanks to the media, any interested person can know today that many diagnoses, such as addiction, psychosis, bipolar disorders, can improve with treatment but at least with the methods at our disposal to present are not treatable disorders, that is, those suffering and their families must learn to live with the disorder. Many patients diagnosed with BPD are wondering if they are in the same case.
actually in many cases of BPD and a variable time after treatment, we are forced to modify the presumptive diagnosis, and not always because that diagnosis was wrong. It is not uncommon that once acute symptoms resolved and reduced the anxiety that they carry with them other pictures emerge underlying masked until then by the storm symptomatic. Circumstance is confirmed by the fact that BPD is a disorder of youth, which often improves with age and that, in general, does not extend beyond the 3 rd or 4 th decade of life. To show what we mean resort to a couple of clinical examples.
For reasons of discretion not give real names or precise, so you will need the confidence of the reader to accept our findings.
Jose is 24, not study or work and spends the day watching TV sunk in their own dreams. At 15, he had a crisis diagnosed as toxic psychosis by cannabis. Since then he has suffered from feelings of emptiness and dissatisfaction of us to avoid imagining that plans unworkable, that even strives to implement. Reacts to frustration with excessive consumption of various drugs, emotional outbursts, bouts of extreme anger and violent behavior, in cycles, causing police intervention and psychiatric admissions.
quiet When you are discharged and the cycle begins again. Parents attribute most of the difficulties of Joseph to drug, so it has undergone various drug treatment has no results. Your symptoms match those of TLP: unstable relationships, impulsivity, emotional instability, aggressive response to frustration, anger inappropriately identity disorders, chronic feelings of emptiness, inability to plan. All therapies attempted so far have been unsuccessful and this does not seem to be very promising, since he seems unwilling to cooperate, is only forced by parents who, naturally, are desperate. Joseph is considered different, but not sick, "my parents are sick, do not let me live my life." The blame for their lack of achievement is always of others, preferably from their parents.
Certain characteristics of his personality (verbiage, rapid speech, expression through metaphors are not always understood by the interlocutor, megalomania) lead us to modify their medication, using the lithium, a mood stabilizer especially useful in bipolar disorders. At the same time, a family interview is an agreement: José back to live with their parents, they did not enter treatment or be forced to inpatient detoxification that he rejects and stop pressing for some time to study or work to give space to his therapy because he was responsible for their situation., in exchange José is committed to try to facilitate coexistence, meet certain minimum standards, to stop using drugs and undergo regular toxicological controls to demonstrate compliance with part of the (something which has refused so far).
The change is dramatic. Joseph is shown to be less aggressive and more stable mood. Increase your ability to reflect, recognize the unreality of his fantasies and lack of any plan to carry out, realize that has lived in a cloud begins to find a training that suits both their preferences as to the reality. Clear that this awareness is not without pain: emerging anguish, sadness and guilt that so far not been demonstrated.
Mary, 38, has long been a psychiatric patient and psicoterpéutica, in some cases with recognized professional and proven ability. Has been diagnosed years ago as well as BPD is presented. And indeed met, and even in excess, the DSM (7 out of 5 required):
1 - unstable personal relationships with alternating idealization and impairment.
2 - Impulsivity.
3 - emotional instability with alternating joy, sadness and irritability.
4 - Inappropriate anger that leads to frequent arguments and fights.
5 - mistaken identity disorders perception of herself and their desires.
6 - Chronic feelings of emptiness.
7 - Efforts to help, so titanic as ineffective.).
The disorder is diagnosed as BPD also according to the criteria of the IEC (6 on 3 required for diagnosis):
* 1-Impulsivity.
* 2-Mood swings. * 3-Disability
planning.
* 4-Response aggressive or self-injurious, to the frustration.
* 5-Impaired self-image and desires. * 6-
so intense and unstable relationships)
The most evident symptoms or at least that she offered to us as such, is the impulsivity and sexual promiscuity, for which she describes as fox and other equally disparaging epithets . The first thing I noted is that the query is not a confessional and we will not judge morally sexual behavior. Emerge
then the compulsive character and unsatisfactory sexual life: it is not seeking love (or what looks wrong, they do not get it) or pleasure, is given to men who denigrate more momentum that desire, can achieve orgasm, but once the relationship invade guilt, emptiness and anguish.
decided then attend the pathological character, symptomatic of a sexuality that, beyond their intensity or frequency, makes you unhappy, no moralizing intent. And we ask her to do the same, and to stop using bad words to describe herself. In a relatively short time learn to not always respond to the desires of others, to say "no" when he believes that the relationship did not prove satisfactory, which does not make you happier, especially with men who do not comply, they do not recognize as a whole human being. Failure to respond to their expectation of moral conviction to interrupt aid short of acting out and self-punishment (guilt) that leads fatally to a new acting and a new fault, repeating the cycle. Restricted
sexual activity, not for moral reasons but because one must try to avoid that which is not good, revalued by herself, Mary begins to question his ambivalent idealization of male Iberian and therapy opens up other problems: trend acting, intense emotional ambivalence, claiming compensation for injustices suffered in childhood. Then ceases to meet the minimum diagnostic criteria required by the canon and emerge Disorder histrionic personality, hitherto concealed by tempestuous symptoms.
personally believe that even though it met the diagnostic criteria of BPD also met with a much earlier diagnosis of classical psychiatry (so forgotten and so useful many times): the hysterical neurosis, which seems to be in worse patient-press family that the supposedly most severe BPD, they are often confused with manipulation hysteria or an insult.
If the diagnosis of BPD was first used Mary to name her discomfort and stop being a weirdo, the questioning of that diagnosis has allowed stop seeing itself as a case, as a patient, to begin to see themselves as a person with psychological difficulties, the first step to take responsibility for their attitude in life and the problems this attitude will produce. Continue antidepressant treatment and dynamic psychotherapy.
Psychotherapy is not a rose garden or work miracles. Joseph and Mary continue to struggle in their therapies and their lives with their illnesses, their symptoms, their problems and, occasionally, suffer a relapse. But situations have lost some of its drama, and this because they begin to envision that their disorders are not a life sentence and begin to sense an output. Also for the family Jose has decreased anxiety. The family of Mary it is more difficult to recognize the progress made by it, remain tied to an image already formed and might eventually come to accompany her, or you may have to stand alone on this path. Time will tell.
increasingly more cases come to consultations with symptoms that, in principle, agree with the TLP. I think because of the reality we live, with a growing demand for individual fitness tests permanently domestic resources, increasing more to come.
In the informative booklet ACAI-TPL characterizes, among other things, as "people, mostly young people who suffer from a kind of personal chaos which sometimes leads them to endanger their lives. " "They try to combat their anxiety and fear that awareness of this situation gives them, clinging to a relationship" quasi-symbolic "with any person, group, sect, and also with drugs, sex, gambling, etc..." "Those who are" hooked "on drugs will stop addicts centers, but" softly "I confess to taking the drug therapist to try to escape his anguish and personal chaos." But this is not what happens to all or almost all young people are hooked on drugs? Do drugs and alcohol are not always a failed attempt to self-medication? , Is the need to always have to reach for an object to escape from the anguish?. This clinical observation has led some psychiatrists Ego American Psicology to postulate that all addiction is a borderline (BPD). Moreover, the excellent description of ACAI-TLP you can find on your website is not describing an increasingly large part of western youth, and as a result of globalization, worldwide?.
As Foucault says, every historical period has developed its own mental illness. Is not the TLP, and generally narcissistic disorders, and complex social and psychological causes, a bad characteristic of the times we live? I do not want to deny this, on the contrary, the existence of individual pathology and diagnostics that allow group and guide us, provided that these diagnoses are not watertight compartments in which to lock up our patients and we're always open to changes occur during the treatment.
diagnoses are not absolute truths but useful tools for our work. Consequently, the category for which we must evaluate is its usefulness. What is a diagnosis or presumptive diagnosis? To guide practitioners in the Choosing the most appropriate medication and management of therapeutic cure.
But BPD, bipolar disorder, unlike for example, lacks, at least for the moment, of a specific medication (antidepressants, anxiolytics, mood stabilizers and even certain antipsychotics may be used depending on the symptoms).
have also been proposed several specific psychotherapeutic techniques for these conditions but, as the American psychiatrist and psychoanalyst Harold Searles, who was the first to propose (in 1965) a specific therapy for BPD, other patients who also suffer from different disorders could benefit from these techniques. What use is it for the patient and their families? To be able to name what is happening, to find a cause to order the situation, to reduce the guilt of the subject, now designated as a patient, suffering from a disease recognized by science, to recognize him as the victim of a mental disorder and not just offender family, your partner, your friends, to generate the expectation once found the disease, also find a cure.
But it can also have undesirable effects: desreponsabilizar the subject, no longer feels responsible for their actions because the responsibility lies with the disorder, enclose the patient in his illness, knowing their thoughts, preferences, desires, demands, which are no longer yours to be considered effects of his illness.
diagnosis at hand can also have another utility that could be called institutional: for patients and families gather together and reclaim the resources promised by the state psychiatric reform but which still lack: Group Therapy, Hospitals Day, accommodations when in a crisis situation it is necessary to temporarily remove the patient and family, specific units Short Income not force them to share those revenues with psychotic patients, which may be counterproductive given the lability symptomatic of BPD. In fact, the Andalusian parliament is drafting a bill to BPD that can be useful.
Conclusions:
Many patients come to the consultation and diagnosis, or self-diagnosed as BPD. Most, not all cases are serious about the serious suffering of the patient and causing his family, but often very different.
In many cases, though not always, this diagnosis is correct. But not all diagnoses are compartmentalized and final. The TLP, with time and proper treatment can be forwarded, reducing suffering and leading to the emergence other underlying disorder.
other hand, psychiatrists and psychotherapists do not attend to cases or diseases or disorders, but individual human beings, complex, not reducible to any diagnosis. Every case is unique because every subject is unique and unrepeatable. We intend to listen to this person, that individual human beings, their discomfort, based on the premise that it is an exceptional case because it is an individual, to which we can not cover with any diagnosis, we believe most diagnostic categories.
Madrid, 1 June 2005
other articles in: Borderline Personality Disorder (BPD), Personality Disorders
0 comments:
Post a Comment